Artificial Intelligence Bots Battle: Bart vs Bing Chat for Podcast Editing Advice
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Bart's Advice for Podcast Editing
- Bing Chat's Podcast Editing Recommendations
- Audio Processing Results
- Conclusion
Introduction to Podcast Editing with AI Assistants
Podcast editing can be a daunting task for beginners. With the rise of AI assistants, there are now new options to get automated help for processing audio and optimizing podcasts. In this post, we will compare two leading conversational AIs - Google's Bart and Microsoft's Bing Chat - to see which one provides better advice for editing podcasts in Adobe Audition.
Specifically, we evaluated their guidance on setting noise reduction, EQ, and compression when working with raw voice recordings. To make it a fair test, both AIs were given the same audio clip and prompt requesting step-by-step recommendations tuned for podcasts.
Comparing Bart and Bing for Podcast Editing
We provided identical prompts to Bart and Bing Chat asking for tips on editing podcasts in Adobe Audition. The goal was to compare the quality and details of the guidance provided by each AI assistant.
Bart's General Podcast Editing Advice
Bart provided decent but very general tips for podcast editing. The advice included using a quiet recording environment, editing audio in small chunks, getting feedback from others, and using professional podcasts as a reference track. However, there were no specific parameter settings or step-by-step workflow provided.
While the tips from Bart are sensible, they lack the nitty gritty details needed for a beginner to actually execute the editing. The information is too generic without concrete examples tailored for our raw podcast recording.
Bart's Tips Lack Specifics
The lack of detailed, step-by-step instructions is the main limitation with Bart's podcast editing advice. Bart seems to provide general knowledge that many beginners may already know rather than technical specifics.
Bing Provides Detailed Podcast Editing Instructions
In contrast to Bart, Bing Chat provided very specific and actionable recommendations for editing podcasts in Adobe Audition. Bing gave step-by-step guidance on setting levels before recording, editing techniques, processing effects to use, and parameters to configure.
For example, Bing suggested using a low shelf EQ filter at 100 Hz with a 3 dB gain, a notch filter at 500 Hz, and a high shelf filter at 15 kHz with a -3 dB cut. The assistant also recommended compression settings like a -20 dB threshold with a 4:1 ratio and makeup gain.
Bing's Technical Precision for Podcast Processing
Unlike the general tips from Bart, Bing provided highly technical instructions for processing the raw podcast recording. The specifics like frequency and dB values demonstrate Bing's ability to give precise editing advice for novices.
Audio Results Using the AI Assistants' Advice
We tested Bing Chat's EQ, compression, and noise reduction recommendations on the raw podcast recording. The audio results were decent, especially for a first pass using automated AI guidance. While not perfect, Bing's settings significantly improved the overall sound compared to the untreated original.
Noise Reduction Cleans Up Background Noise
Using Bing's suggested noise reduction settings, the background noise and room tone were effectively minimized without negatively impacting the voice audio. The noise floor was substantially reduced compared to the raw recording.
EQ Settings Improve Tonal Balance
The EQ settings provided by Bing helped improve the tonal balance by attenuating boxy mids and adding clarity on the low and high ends. The sound is more balanced and pleasant than the untreated original.
Compression Configuration Levels Out Volume
With Bing's recommended compression applied, the dynamic range was controlled to even out the volume fluctuations in the raw audio. The instructor's voice is more consistent with fewer volume spikes and drops.
Conclusion
Comparing the two AI assistants, Bing Chat clearly provided superior podcast editing recommendations than Bart. While Bart had general wisdom, Bing gave actionable and detailed advice tailored for podcast processing in Adobe Audition.
The parameter settings and processing workflow from Bing resulted in significantly better audio quality compared to the raw recording. This demonstrates the power of advanced AI's to automate editing tasks for novices learning podcast production.
Bing Delivers More Advanced Podcast Editing Advice
In conclusion, Bing Chat is currently better than Bart for podcast editing guidance based on the technical precision and audio improvements. As AI technology progresses, we can expect even more advanced automated assistance for creative workflows like podcast production.
FAQ
Q: What was the podcast editing challenge?
A: The challenge was to get the best advice from AI assistants Bart and Bing Chat on how to edit a podcast in Adobe Audition.
Q: What kind of advice did Bart provide?
A: Bart gave more general podcast editing tips like using a quiet recording environment and editing audio in small chunks.
Q: How detailed was Bing Chat's advice?
A: Bing Chat provided very specific settings and steps for applying effects like noise reduction, EQ, and compression in Adobe Audition.
Q: Which AI performed better?
A: Overall, Bing Chat provided more detailed and helpful advice for the podcast editing challenge.
Q: What were the audio processing results?
A: By following Bing Chat's instructions, the audio quality improved with reduced noise, clearer EQ, and more even compression.
Q: What was the conclusion of the AI comparison?
A: The conclusion was that Bing Chat is currently more advanced than Bart for step-by-step audio editing advice, although Bart can be useful for general tips.
Q: How can I edit my podcasts better?
A: Follow Bing Chat's recommendations for applying effects like noise reduction, EQ adjustments, compression settings, and other enhancements in your digital audio workstation.
Q: What software was used?
A: The podcast audio was edited with effects in Adobe Audition based on advice from the Bart and Bing Chat AI assistants.
Q: Where can I learn more about podcast editing?
A: There are many online tutorials and courses available for learning podcast production and editing skills.
Q: What other AI assistants are available?
A: Beyond Bart and Bing, there are other AI assistants like Google Assistant, Alexa, Siri, and more that may be helpful for certain podcast editing tasks.